The tune of “Hallelujah” was used to set the Arabic lines from “Ya Ilahi (Oh My Lord)” by the Kuwaiti singer Muhammad Al Husayn. From its first solo piano performance, Mennel’s cover evolved into an eight-string acoustic folk instrument, whose exotic lead intertwined with the vocal melody, adding a new dimension to the sound.

When her performance aired in France, Mennel—who is of Syrian-Turkish and Moroccan-Algerian descent—made quite a sensation in the media. Fans remarked on her magnificent voice, majestic features, and eye-catching blue turban, highlighting the importance of French Muslim women’s representation in the prominent competition. You can see Mennel perform “Hallelujah” and “Say Something” by A Great Big World on America’s Got Talent; the performance is available below.